Cast
Mackenzie Shirilla
Self
Tim Troup
Self - Assistant Prosecutor
Rosie Graham
Self - Friend
Bubba Turner
Self - Friend
Faythe Walsh
Self - Childhood Friend
Steve Shirilla
Self - Mackenzie's Father
Natalie Shirilla
Self - Mackenzie's Mother
Frank Russo
Self - Dominic's Father
Christy Russo
Self - Dominic's Mother
Angelo Russo
Self - Dominic's Brother
Christine Russo
Self - Dominic's Sister
Davyne Flanagan
Self - Davion's Sister
Scott Flanagan
Self - Davion's Father
Jaime Flanagan
Self - Davion's Mother
Dominic Russo
Self (archive footage)
Davion Flanagan
Self (archive footage)
Elliot Rawson
Self - Ohio State Highway Patrol
Ryan Fox
Self - Ohio State Highway Patrol
James McDonnell
Self - Mackenzie Shirilla's Lawyer
Nancy M. Russo
Self - Judge
Christopher Martin
Self - Christy Russo's Friend
More like this
The Menendez Brothers
7.2
2024
Voyeur
5.9
2017
Maternal Instinct
7.1
2026
A Toxic Love Story
6.4
2026
Evil Influencer: The Jodi Hildebrandt Story
6.2
2025
Out of Thin Air
5.9
2017
Aileen: Queen of the Serial Killers
6.9
2025
Con Mum
6.8
2025
Ted Bundy: Mind of a Monster
7.6
2019
The Killing of America
7.2
1981
Untold: Crime & Penalties
7.1
2021
Why Did You Kill Me?
5.9
2021
Abducted in Plain Sight
6.6
2017
Unknown Number: The High School Catfish
6.8
2025
H.H. Holmes: America's First Serial Killer
6.2
2004
My Mom Jayne
8.0
2025
Boys State
7.1
2020
How to Rob a Bank
6.7
2024
BRATS
6.1
2024
To Kill a Tiger
7.6
2023