Cast
Keegan-Michael Key
Buddy the Unicorn (voice)
Cristin Milioti
Grace
Delaney Quinn
Freddy
Caleb Williams
Wade
Madison Skyy Polan
Hannah
Tristan Borders
Oliver
Patton Oswalt
Strappy (voice)
Jimmica Collins
Betty Bunny (voice)
Eric Bauza
Mr. Mailbox / Worry Well / Couchy / Trashy / Pee Flower (voice)
Topher Grace
Ben
Bryson JonSteele
Derek
Seamus Flynn
Timothy
Luke Speakman
Josh
Bennie Taylor
Mailman Miles
Phuong Kubacki
Nurse Nancy
Devon Hawkes Ludlow
Charlie the Train (voice)
Michael Shannon
Willie (voice)
Clint Howard
George
Sergey Zhuravsky
Buddy the Unicorn (suit)
Jonathan Yurco
Dark Buddy (suit)
Cedwan Hooks
Betty Bunny (suit)
Mark Aaron Buerkle
Therapist (Day Player)
Conner Stumm
Mailman Justin
Eric Salazar
Grilling Man
Lynette Eklund
Puppeteer
Tory J. Malone
Tyler
Brooke Bloom
Dr. Deborah Burr
Rachel Appelbaum
Clocky / Mr. Mailbox (uncredited)
Frank Brown Jr.
Father (uncredited)
More like this
Death of a Unicorn
6.4
2025
Constantine: City of Demons - The Movie
7.7
2018
Fright Night
6.3
2011
Onyx the Fortuitous and the Talisman of Souls
6.0
2023
The Witches of Eastwick
6.5
1987
Wes Craven's New Nightmare
6.5
1994
Mockingbird Lane
6.2
2012
Dark Harvest
6.1
2023
Tales from the Darkside: The Movie
6.2
1990
Parents
5.9
1989
Fright Night
7.0
1985
A Haunted House 2
6.2
2014
All About Evil
5.9
2010
There's Something in the Barn
6.1
2023
PG: Psycho Goreman
6.0
2020
Extra Ordinary
6.4
2019
Creepshow 2
6.2
1987
The Gate
6.1
1987
Deadstream
6.3
2022
Nightbreed
6.4
1990